A San Diego yoga instructor, Steve Hubbard, known as “NamaSteve,” has filed a third lawsuit against the city of San Diego for citing him for teaching public yoga classes.
The lawsuit challenges a city ordinance that bans most yoga instruction in parks and beaches, arguing it violates First Amendment rights. Hubbard’s legal battle began after he received citations in 2025, despite a federal court ruling that the city’s ordinance was unconstitutional.
Hubbard’s lawsuit claims he was cited on May 6, 2025, just months after a federal judge ruled the ordinance “substantially overburdens speech.” The city of San Diego continues to enforce the ban, arguing that the classes constitute commercial activity, as attendees often make donations. However, Hubbard contends that his classes are free and open to all, with donations being voluntary.
The city has subpoenaed financial records of Hubbard and fellow instructor Amy Baack, seeking evidence of commercial activity. Attorney Bryan Pease, representing Hubbard, has moved to quash these subpoenas, arguing they infringe on privacy rights. A San Diego Superior Court judge will decide on the subpoenas at a hearing on Thursday.
Despite the legal challenges, Hubbard remains committed to offering yoga classes, which he views as a service to the community. He has resumed teaching at Pacific Beach, drawing support from residents who see the classes as a community asset.
The ongoing legal battle highlights tensions between city regulations and public use of open spaces. The outcome of the case could set a precedent for similar disputes over public park use across the country.
Recent Comments