A California appeals court has struck down a voter ID law in Huntington Beach, ruling that it violates state law. The law, approved by voters in March 2024, required residents to show identification at polling places for local elections. However, it was never implemented.
The California Fourth Appellate District Court of Appeal’s decision was based on the argument that local voter ID requirements conflict with state election laws. The ruling was issued by a three-judge panel, including Justices Joanne Motoike, Thomas Delaney, and Maurice Sanchez, who concluded that voter identification is a matter of national concern and not within the jurisdiction of individual cities.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta and Secretary of State Shirley Weber had previously sued Huntington Beach, arguing that the measure could disenfranchise voters and was preempted by state law. Bonta praised the court’s decision, stating that “California’s elections are already fair, safe, and secure,” and emphasized the importance of protecting voting rights. Weber also criticized the city for its attempt to implement the voter ID law, stating that it wasted taxpayer dollars.
Huntington Beach officials, known for their history of challenging state regulations, are currently reviewing the court’s decision and considering their next steps. The city spokesperson, Corbin Carson, indicated that the city is evaluating the ruling.
The appeals court’s decision overturns a previous ruling by OC Superior Court Judge Nico Dourbetas, who had sided with the city earlier this year. The case highlights ongoing debates over voter ID laws and their impact on voting rights across the United States.
Recent Comments